tradition of reading it interpreting it copying it handing it down right you can't separate those things out i mean you can verbally but in reality you cannot pry those those things apart so all that said now this time you see the instructions are a little different he says go to the rock Now, let me point out, if you're looking for evidence in the text for that tradition, notice God says, the rock. Which rock? Right? If this was just another random rock, he'd have to tell him which one, right? It's not like there's only one rock in the Sinai Desert, right? There's a couple. Or go find a rock. Right? Right? Go to the rock I direct you to. Right? Go to this rock, right? That's what he says, go to the rock. So apparently Moses immediately knew what rock it was. So this could be taken as evidence that that whole following them thing is implied here, even though not stated. But he says, go and speak to it. And when he speaks to it, God will give the Israelites water. verse 9. So Moses took the rod from before the Lord as the Lord ordered him. So he took it from before the Lord. Remember, this is Aaron's rod. Remember, it budded, and they put it in the most holy place. So they went in there to talk to God. Moses goes and takes the rod. And Moses and Aaron And get. gathered the congregation together before the rock. And he, Moses, said to them, Hear me, you disobedient ones. Must we bring water for you out of this rock? Now this already should set up the danger of Will Robinson, right? Like, we, Moses and Aaron, are going to bring them water out of the rock? Or Moses and God? But wait, it gets worse. Verse 11, Moses then lifted his hand and struck the rock twice with his rod. And water came out abundantly, and the congregation and their cattle drank. Wasn't supposed to hit the rock. Wasn't supposed to hit the rock twice. Wasn't supposed to present it as, oh, here's Moses and Aaron are going to do a magic trick and give you water. What did hitting the rock symbolize the first time? God accepting the judgment of the people giving them water and giving them life nonetheless so what is Moses doing when he strikes the rock he's judging God in front of the people and taking credit for the water they're about to get because he's angry at them